COMMENTARY / LGBT

Why I am NOT going to the “1st Annual Sequin de Mayo Chola Pageant” in Austin, Texas

alibi_lacuca-1

Why I am NOT going to the “1st Annual Sequin de Mayo Chola Pageant” in Austin, Texas

by: Raquel Rodriguez & Community Allies 

“We can take things that are ugly, politically incorrect, and difficult to think about and bring them forward in a way that gets people thinking.” – Poo Poo Platter

I will not be going to Poo Poo Platter’s “1st Annual Sequin de Mayo Chola Pageant,” and this is why:

*************** Racist programming like this is actually a big deal***************

We, as members of Austin’s queer community and allies, want to support artistic expression and the right of every individual to tell their own story. We appreciate using drag to transgress society’s norms, and our community’s role in showing that there are other ways of being in the world that deserve to be honored and respected.

It is in that spirit that we want to draw attention to a disturbing trend in our community: that is the widespread racism, and apologies for racism, we see on a regular basis. This week, Poo Poo Platter, a “monthly sh*t show of drag variety” is holding their: “1st Annual Sequin de Mayo Chola Pageant.” This is just one expression of an even more widespread acceptance and normalization of bigoted attitudes.

Many people have tried to reach out to the organizers about re-theming and reprogramming the problematic elements about the show; and although they have changed some of the elements, the offensive essence remains intact.

050313PooPooPlatter

For example, originally the image associated with the Facebook event was a “Chola” behind bars, but it was later changed after it was brought to the programmer’s attention. This original problematic image reinforces ideas that Latinos/as are prone to crime, which is a way anti-immigrant racism is justified, and emphasizes the legitimacy of the prison system. Poo Poo Platter’s current Facebook event image of a “Chola-fied” “Honey Boo Boo” is an equally offensive image that does nothing to transgress the current mainstream imagery and representation of cholas but rather emphasizes a template and chola-meme on Tumblr..

In defense of the show’s elements and presentation, Poo Poo Platter’s organizers and performers have said:

“The show intends to challenge the mainstream social norms”… “be campy”… “that it is harmless”… “not a big deal” or …“it’s to be funny.”

Programming like this may seem “fun” and “harmless”  but it relies on racist, exoticizing, and objectifying tropes for content that legitimizes racism and  reinforces and serves as an agent to normalize harmful mainstream stereotypes and norms. A “Chola Pageant” requires participants to essentially “perform” racial caricatures that are based on stereotypes rooted in fear. Such racialized imagery  has been used as a means of control and have played a significant role in reinforcing racist and sexist gazes, thoughts, attitudes, and perceptions leading to various form of violence and oppression including: lynchings, deep-rooted prejudices, low self-esteem, and depression.

Poo Poo Platter says: “We as a troupe consist of 7 people, 4 of which are of Hispanic/Latino ethnicity and background” and “4 out 5 contestants that have agreed to perform are also of Hispanic/Latino ethnicity.”

With this aforementioned reasoning, Poo Poo Platter programmers imply that because, “Hispanics” and “Latinos” are involved in the programming in all aspects, the pageant event can not be “racist” or be considered “Brownface.” The event is therefore, according to Poo Poo Platter, appropriate and unquestionable, because a few people who identify as “Latino” or “Hispanic,” do not feel offended. However, the feelings of these few do not represent all “Latinos/as” and “Hispanics,” or the rest of the Austin community for that matter.

Identifying the “Latino” or “Hispanic” members of the Poo Poo troupe is not evidence of work being done to safeguard against the objectification and exoticization of Latino communities, such selected emphasis is actually a “tokenizing” tactic.

I presented my concerns to “Poo Poo Platter” about Black/Brown/Red/Yellow-face, and that it relies on the marketability of exoticization of people of color and the commodification of their cultures; contributes to a capitalistic-hegemonic straight white standard of beauty; and that it depends on an audience that would find pleasure in entertainment that makes fun of, objectifies and dehumanizes a group of people that have complex-beautiful cultures and histories.

In response Poo Poo Platter said, “You have stated that our intention for our next show makes fun of, objectifies, and dehumanizes a group of complex-beautiful culture and histories. We are not by any means ‘normalizing’ stereotypes but providing a show that is based off Latino culture and comedic representations. We are not saying ‘all Mexicans are poor people that wash dishes and build houses.’ We are taking actual common interests of Latin people (cholas, low riders, and various forms of dress) and combining them into an event that is simply meant to be fun and engage our audience.”

Poo Poo Platter says, they have the intention to be “fun” and “engage their audience,” but whom is having the fun and at what expense? They say they intend to challenge social norms, but what norms are being challenged and which norms are being reinforced? They say they are providing an opportunity for people to empower themselves, but who is actually being empowered and at what cost? Poo Poo Platter says, their shows intends to bring forward things that are “ugly,” “politically incorrect” and “difficult to think about,” but what about the programming has been presented that is challenging to what is already present about “Chola” or “Pageant” Culture?

This type of programming is symptomatic of the racism that has been tolerated and allowed to permeate through the Austin community; where racist and problematic parties, events, and performances masquerade as “shock drag,” “challenging,” “creative entertainment,” or as “adoration.”.

Today I say Ya Basta! Enough!

c/s

 

Guest writer, Raquel Rodriguez is an out, proud, and loud about it Razquache Queer Chicana Tejana, Y Que?

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Why I am NOT going to the “1st Annual Sequin de Mayo Chola Pageant” in Austin, Texas

  1. You………….are way too easily offended. I’m curious; are you even in a small part hispanic? Because I am, and don’t find it offensive at all. Maybe let us defend ourselves if we feel the need to? Because, you know, we got knives and guns.

  2. Okay, I see now that at least your name is. Still. Surely there’s way more important issues to be outraged about.

    • Telling someone their concern is unimportant and/or that they should focus on something else is a well-established derailment tactic, however well-intended.

      If a member of a marginalized community raises an objection related to an area of their marginalization, they deserve to be heard, not silenced.

  3. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this event – I think it’s a very interesting perspective. I’m curious though – are there times when it would be acceptable to have a form of entertainment about “cholas”? Is the issue with the way this show is being done, or the fact that it’s portraying this at all? Is there an issue with the term “chola” itself, or who is using it? What type of situations or forums is it appropriate to talk about the historical context of this term or form of expression – does adding humor do a disservice? These are just questions to help my understanding.

    I remember when I was growing up, I had a “chola” phase. I didn’t know that’s what it was called until years later and I heard the term used (can’t remember by whom). But from 7th-8th grade I wore dark lip liner, dark eye liner, lots of jewelry, had big bangs, read Lowrider magazine, listened to Latin hip hop and had a good time with it all until I started meeting other people who weren’t really into it. I guess I wasn’t really into it either, otherwise I would have kept it. I was influenced by my cousins who I wanted to be like because I thought they were cool and popular. Being a “chola” was something I felt embarrassed about throughout high school – I would make my dad hide the chola pictures of me anytime someone came over. I didn’t want my new friends to see pictures of me as a chola. I thought it was something to be ashamed about. Now, I’m in my late 20s and I think, I’m glad I had that. I think it was a form of expression I chose because I didn’t have my own. Expression and how it evolves is a reflection of socialization and different forms of “fitting in.”

    Anyway, that’s my story. But if someone like NPR or New York Times were to do a story about something like this, which they already have, are those things offensive? Is it judged on a case-by-case basis? Who gets to represent these things? So many questions!

    • Your point about the group justifying the show because they have Hispanics/Latinos in the group is spot on. Really glad that someone shared this post with us today. Great piece.

  4. WTF? You don’t find this in the least bit offensive?! Then my friends, the powers that be have brainwashed you into believing you are something you are not or ever will be. One of fhem.

  5. @not easily offended- Im entertained by the use of last names to prove some sort of race essentialism- can one not be of a particular background based in ethnic and political identity that stems from cultural and social origins and have a non normative name to the group. Meaning, just because Bobby Jindal is brown does not mean he is down for south asian liberation and rights in the states ya dig

  6. I say don’t judge till you’ve seen it. This kind of PC preemptive strike smacks of censorship. Until you’ve seen it, you have no idea what the show is about and can’t criticize it for what you imagine it to be.

    • It’s not “censorship” to point out that the descriptions provided for the event are racist. It’s just acknowledging that those things are racist.

  7. Your diatribe is retro a la 70’s but your point is well taken. However as a big tex-mex fag of 61 I point out that drag is farce and goes back further then a greek putting on a dress in 500BC.
    If a bunch of fellow jotos want to dress up and mock their hyperMaybelined hermanas then let them. Just don’t go.
    The ongoing friction between drag and feminist ideals is not going to be solved here. Probably never.
    What is racist and ignorant is hipsters running around in ponchos, bright sombreros, and fake mustaches drinking $50 dollar bottles of tequila. Yet I laugh at their stupidity and cluelessness.
    Maybe that’s what you should do Ms Rodriguez. Especially at Poo Poo Platter who obviously wants us to know she/he is all about serving up shit.

  8. I agree that this type of show IS racist drivel. What is your opinion on drag shows that a. have only queens, not kings, and b. poke fun of women in the most misogynistic ways imaginable, such as singing songs about cunt smelling like fish? (I saw a show like this a while ago and was extremely offended, but the people around me, including cis women, adored it).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s